Bass Player Buyer's Guide
BASS GUITAR - P BASS OR J BASS?
Body
-
Both have a similar body style, although the Jazz Bass has a slightly offset body at the waist.
-
Weight wise, they are pretty similar
Pickups
-
P Bass: One split-coil pickup in the middle position. This design creates a thick, warm low-end sound that is characteristic of many classic rock and soul recordings.
-
J Bass: Two single-coil pickups, one near the bridge and one near the neck. This allows for more tonal variety. You can select either pickup or blend them together. The bridge pickup provides a brighter, more modern sound, while the neck pickup produces a warmer, more traditional tone.
Controls
-
P Bass: Volume knob, tone knob
-
J Bass: Two volume knobs (one for each pickup), tone knob. This allows for more precise control over the overall sound.
Neck
-
P Bass: Typically has a thicker neck profile, which some players find easier to hold onto for fingerstyle playing.
-
J Bass: Typically has a thinner neck profile, which many players find more comfortable for fast, technical playing. The neck profile of Jazz Basses can vary depending on the year it was made.
Sound
-
P Bass: Known for its warm, thick, and punchy sound. It's a classic sound that works well in a variety of genres, from rock and blues to country and funk.
-
J Bass: Offers a wider variety of sounds due to its two pickups. It can produce a bright, modern sound with the bridge pickup, a warm, vintage tone with the neck pickup, or a blend of both.
Versatility
-
P Bass: Considered to be a very versatile bass guitar despite having just one pickup.
-
J Bass: Generally considered more versatile than the P Bass due to its wider tonal range.
Playing Style
-
P Bass: A good choice for players who prefer a simple, straightforward instrument with a classic sound. It's also popular among fingerstyle players who appreciate the thicker neck profile.
-
J Bass: A good choice for players who want a more versatile instrument with a wider range of tonal possibilities. The thinner neck profile is popular among players who like to slap and play fast technical passages.
Here are some additional factors to consider when choosing between a P Bass and a J Bass:
-
Your budget: P Basses are generally less expensive than J Basses.
-
Your musical style: If you play a lot of rock, blues, or country, a P Bass might be a good choice. If you play a wider variety of genres, or if you want a more versatile instrument, a J Bass might be a better option.
-
Your playing style: If you prefer a thicker neck profile, a P Bass might be more comfortable for you. If you prefer a thinner neck profile, a J Bass might be a better choice.
Ultimately, the best way to decide which bass is right for you is to try out both of them and see which one you prefer.
ACTIVE VS PASSIVE BASS GUITARS: PROS AND CONS
Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons of active vs passive electric bass guitars:
Passive Basses:
Pros:
-
Simpler design: Less circuitry, generally more reliable and require less maintenance.
-
Warmer tone: Many players prefer the natural, uncolored sound of passive basses.
-
Lighter weight: No preamp means a slightly lighter instrument.
-
Lower cost: Generally less expensive than active basses.
Cons:
-
Less tonal control: Limited EQ options for shaping your sound.
-
Lower output: May require turning up your amp more to achieve desired volume, impacting battery life.
-
Susceptible to signal loss: Long cable runs can lead to signal degradation.
Active Basses:
Pros:
-
Greater tonal control: Built-in preamp with EQ allows for more sculpting of your sound (bass, mid, treble).
-
Higher output: Can achieve greater volume levels without needing to crank your amp.
-
Less signal loss: Better suited for longer cable runs with minimal signal degradation.
Cons:
-
More complex design: Preamp circuitry can be more prone to failure and requires battery changes.
-
Potential for colored tone: Some players find the active preamp alters the natural sound of the bass.
-
Heavier weight: Preamp adds a little extra weight to the instrument.
-
Higher cost: Generally more expensive than passive basses.
Choosing Between Active and Passive:
-
Sound preference: If you prefer a warm, uncolored tone, go passive. If you need more tonal flexibility, go active.
-
Playing style: Slap bassists often prefer the brighter attack of active basses. Passive basses may be better for laid-back styles.
-
Budget: Passive basses are generally more affordable.
-
Gigging needs: Consider how much control you need over your sound and if long cable runs are a concern.
The Bottom Line:
There's no right or wrong answer. Both active and passive basses can produce excellent tones. Try out both types and see which feels and sounds better for you!
BASS SCALE LENGTH: KEY POINTS
-
Scale Length: Distance of vibrating string section (bridge to nut).
-
Types: Short (up to 30"), Medium (30-33"), Long (34"), Extra-Long (35"+)
-
A Fender Bronco Bass typically falls into the Short scale length category at 30 inches
-
-
Most Basses: Long Scale (inherited from Fender Precision Bass)
Choosing Scale Length:
-
Tone:
-
Longer scale = More tension, stiffer strings, brighter highs, "piano-like" tone.
-
Shorter scale = Richer low-end, smoother high-end.
-
Short scale basses can sound really huge because of this. Plug in a Ubass to see.
-
-
-
Playability: Longer scales can be physically demanding due to fret spacing, especially for smaller hands.
-
Short scale basses are a good option for beginners or players with smaller hands.
-
Remember: There's no right answer! Try different scales and choose what feels most comfortable and sounds best for you.
EXTENDED-RANGE BASSES (5 & 6 STRINGS): KEY POINTS
Extended-range basses, also known as 5-string or 6-string basses, offer bassists a wider range of notes compared to the standard 4-string bass. This opens doors for new techniques, tonal possibilities, and greater flexibility in playing.
Pros:
-
Extended Range:
-
Adds a low B string (sometimes even a high C string on 6-strings) for deeper, heavier tones.
-
Offers more options for playing solos and exploring higher harmonic registers.
-
-
Greater Versatility:
-
Can cover both bass and guitar lines in some situations.
-
Useful in genres like jazz/fusion, prog-metal, and for bassists who want to push boundaries.
-
Cons:
-
Playability:
-
Longer scale length (35"+) to maintain tension on the low B string can make fret stretching more difficult, especially in the lower positions.
-
Wider neck requires adaptation and proper technique to avoid injury.
-
Increased weight due to extra strings and reinforced neck can be tiring during long playing sessions.
-
Other Considerations:
-
String Tension:
-
Extra strings put more tension on the neck, so extended-range basses often have thicker necks with truss rods for adjustments.
-
-
Balance and Comfort:
-
Look for instruments with good balance to distribute the weight comfortably.
-
-
Cost:
-
Extended-range basses are generally more expensive than standard 4-string basses.
-
Final Decision:
Extended-range basses offer exciting sonic possibilities, but require adjustments in playing style due to the increased neck width and fret spacing. If you're looking to expand your tonal palette and explore new musical territory, an extended-range bass can be a great choice. However, it's important to weigh the pros and cons, considering your playing style, budget, and physical comfort.